Hi Johanna, just wanted to give you an update. After talking on the phone with Apple support my problem was resolved. It was a somewhat lengthy process and I wish I could recall all the steps, but in brief, we signed into My Apple ID with my current email address. We then went through Edit where I typed in every email address I have including the old inactive email address. From there we were able to locate the old email address and delete it and then finally adding my current email back into the system. Like I said, I wish I could recall all the steps involved but I hope you can kind of follow me. I am very relieved that the problem is solved, and I do thank you for all your help.