I'm a heavy-user PC girl, Android smartphone fan and a very very happy iPad2 owner.
The thing that I hate most about the iPad is its file management system and iTunes in particular. By contrast, you plug an Android device to a PC and it is automatically recognized as a standard USB key without the use of any 3rd party app or driver and you can effortlessly transfer files back and forth between PC and Android.
I love Android and hate iTunes, yet for a tablet I went for an iPad2 and don't regret it, why?
- to my knowledge, no Android tablet beats the iPad in terms for battery live (really really amazing on the iPad), lightweightness and screen quality (the iPad is useable under sun/bright light), fluidity/reponsiveness/stability (rotation, moving around between screen,etc...)
- the great choice of app is amazing, notably with regards to games/educations/multimedia apps (that I wouldn't use on a smartphone anyways because the screen is too small). If you limit yourself to watching photos or editing them I guess maybe Android or iPad won't make much difference, but once you'll have a Tablet in your hands... you'll be tempted to use all its multimedia/leisure features (especially if you have kids). And frankly, I doubt you can do much precise photo editing by the tip of your fingers (I've not tested, I can't say... I still prefer my photoshop). If you chose to go for Android, go to the XDA-Dev forum for Q&A, HowTo, help to chose the best model/brand that will feed your needs (Android requires more geek aptitude than Apple devices for best power usage...
)
Now coming back to iTunes, you can do things without iTunes:
- You can transfer photos back and forth between iPad and PC without iTunes: from iPad to PC when you plug the iPad to PC iPad pops up as a USB key in the PC BUT only photos are available. From PC to iPad you can use the special kit sold by apple (or third parties on
ebay). Not highy convenient, but feasible.
- There are several apps available in the market that use wifi to transfer photos back and forth between the iPad and your PC (i've not tested any of them, because I find wifi too slow especially for a large batch of photos and because I use the option below)
- If you Jailbreak your iPad (tuto available here in the forum, easy and no risk), then bye bye itunes (for most usage). Jaibreaking means freeing your iPad from most of Apple's (stupid IMHO) constrains. I've jailbroken my iPad2 and use a combo of 2 file managers: iFile on the iPad and iFunbox on the PC. With this combo, it is almost as if your iPad was a USB key. iFunBox can be run as a simple exe (no installer) so it can be use on any PC without being intrusive. iFile includes a wifi module so can be accessed from a PC without even using iFunbox.
IMHO, you can do OK without JB but the best option (for convenience and ease of use) is iPad + JB. However if you want to JailBreak, you need to have you iPad with iOS 4.3.3 not 4.3.4... so you need to hurry and buy an iPad that was already in stock in the retail store before July 16 when Apple released iOS 4.3.4 (the upgrade was meant to block the 4.3.3 JailBreak ). You cannot downgrade from 4.3.4 to 4.3.3 if you did not own a 4.3.3 version before hand... There may be some non-permanent JB for 4.3.4 but i'm not sure. For all JB questions see the very good iPad Hacking section in this forum.
With regard to charging the iPad through the PC, it depends on the strength of the usb port... on my laptop it is not powerful enough but on some PC (tower) it could be OK.
Last comment: don't hesitate to buy a 64 Go iPad... I have a 32 Go iPad and very much miss the additional 32 Go (those multimedia apps are great but eat a lot of space...).
Hopes this help
Surfinette
EDIT : iPad can read raw files , I don't know for Android (not tested)